The Tiny house Blog

Composting Toilets Vs. Traditional Toilets

Updated on:
April 17, 2024
Composting Toilets Vs. Traditional Toilets

Image Source: Canva

You've probably heard of composting toilets as a sustainable alternative to traditional ones, but do you really know the differences? Consider how these toilets leverage natural processes to transform waste into compost, saving water and reducing pollution in the process. 

Yet, they demand more of your time and attention than the traditional flush-and-forget types. While they might be pricier upfront, think about the long-term savings on your water bill and the environmental impact. Want to know more about this intriguing comparison? Let's continue.

Understanding Traditional Toilets

Let's dive into the world of traditional toilets, your everyday bathroom essential that operates on a water-based flushing system. You've undoubtedly used them countless times, but have you ever considered how they work?

Here's a quick rundown. When you flush, water in the tank rushes into the bowl, creating a siphon effect that draws waste and toilet paper into the sewer line. It's an efficient system, but it's not perfect. You're essentially using clean, treated water to transport waste. Furthermore, if there's a blockage in your sewer line, you could end up with a messy problem on your hands.

In the next section, we'll explore a different kind of toilet that addresses some of these issues: the composting toilet.

Basics of Composting Toilets

Shifting gears to composting toilets, you'll find they're an innovative solution that tackles some of the problems inherent in traditional systems. Unlike your standard toilet, a composting toilet doesn't need water. Instead, it uses aerobic bacteria to break down waste into compost.

Now you're probably wondering, what's the process? First, you deposit waste into a container, just like a regular toilet. You then add materials like wood shavings to assist in the composting process.

As time goes by, the aerobic bacteria get to work and break down the waste. After a period, usually a few months, you're left with nutrient-rich compost. It's a fantastic way to recycle waste, and it doesn't come with the typical downsides of a traditional flush toilet.

Environmental Impact Comparison

When comparing the environmental impacts, you'll find composting toilets offer significant advantages over traditional models. These eco-friendly alternatives conserve water, a vital resource, by operating without flushing. It's a stark contrast to regular toilets that can use up to 3.5 gallons per flush. Moreover, they prevent harmful sewage and nutrients from entering water bodies, thus reducing pollution and protecting aquatic life.

The compost produced is a rich soil conditioner, which boosts plant growth, negating the need for chemical fertilizers. Furthermore, composting toilets reduce greenhouse gas emissions, as the waste isn't transported or treated in energy-intensive facilities.

Assessing Practicality and Convenience

While the environmental benefits are clear, you might wonder about the practicality and convenience of composting toilets. They're more compact than traditional ones, making them ideal for small spaces. You'll find they don't require a connection to a sewer line or septic system, which is great for remote areas.

However, they do need regular emptying, which could be a hassle if you're not used to it. The smell can also be an issue if they're not properly managed. While there's no flushing involved, some models do require a small amount of water or additives to aid in composting.

Cost and Maintenance Analysis

Examining the cost and maintenance of composting toilets, it's crucial to consider both the upfront price and the ongoing expenses.

Typically, composting toilets are more expensive to purchase initially than traditional toilets. You're looking at a range from several hundred to over a thousand dollars, depending on the model and features you choose.

However, the ongoing costs can be lower. You don't have water bills, as these units don't require a water connection. The only regular expense is for the composting medium, which isn't costly.

Maintenance involves regular emptying of the compost, which you can do yourself, saving on plumber costs. So, while the upfront cost may seem daunting, the long-term savings are worth considering.

Using Composting Toilets

Composting Toilets in Urban Environments

Yes, you can use composting toilets in urban environments. They're eco-friendly and require no plumbing. They convert waste into compost.

However, it's important to check local regulations as some cities may have restrictions.

Health Implications of Using Composting Toilets

You're unlikely to face health risks from composting toilets if properly maintained. They're designed to safely decompose waste, but improper use can lead to harmful bacteria.

Always follow the manufacturer's guidelines for safe and healthy use.

Composting Toilets On Attracting Pests or Creating Unpleasant Odors

Yes, if you're not careful, composting toilets can attract pests and produce unpleasant odors. Proper maintenance, like regular emptying and proper ventilation, is vital to prevent these issues.

They aren't inherent problems, though.

Legal Restrictions on the Use of Composting Toilets

Sure, there can be legal restrictions on composting toilets. It's dependent on local health codes and zoning laws.

You'll need to check with your local government to ensure you're in compliance before installing one.

Composting Toilets Requiring a Specific Type of Waste Disposal

Yes, composting toilets do require a specific type of waste disposal.

You'd need to regularly empty the compost bin and dispose of it properly, usually by adding it to a compost pile or bin in your yard.


So, you're weighing up composting toilets against traditional ones. They're eco-friendly, water-saving, and perfect for remote spots. Sure, they need a bit more upkeep and cost more initially, but they're worth it in the long run.

Plus, you'll be doing your bit for the planet. It's a win-win. Ultimately, the choice is yours. But remember, every small step towards sustainability counts.

Did you enjoy this post and find value in it? Share it with your friends with the links below!

Need more info? Get

By submitting your email, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms

Subscribe to get the latest news

This is a new way to communicate faster than any communication platforms

Thank you!
Your submission has been received! Check your inbox for an email from with more info!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again or email us at Thanks!
Want all the latest tiny house inspo and news?

Get free resources, updates, tips & tricks, and special offers by joining the Tiny House Plan Newsletter.

No items found.

Frequently Asked Questions

Find answers — straight from the author — for the most common questions about this article.

Don't see your question here? Contact us!
No items found.

Join The Tiny House Community

Occasionally: Community Events, DIY Tips and Tricks, Tiny House Guides
Never: Junk or Spam and we don't sell or misuse your email.
Welcome to the fam! We're excited to have you join the community.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again or use the form below.